
Posting a comment on someone’s website is like walking into their dining room and pulling a chair up to the table. If it’s your dining room table it can be a bit of a shock when someone shows up.
Now, that is not to say it is necessarily a bad thing to have someone pop in. It can lead to some interesting and stimulating exchanges. And most of the time the discours is really quite enjoyable.
On the other hand, lacing your comments with profanity and insults is rather like sitting up to their table and breaking free with a horrendous blast of flatulence. While no one may actually say anything about it, they may consider locking the door for the next meal.
Here are some guides I try to follow when commenting.
- Value added. If I have nothing to say that adds value to the post, I don’t comment.
- Consider email. If I have something of a personal nature to address with the author, I consider contacting them by email.
- Hanlon’s Razor. If I draft a comment that can be construed to be “out of line” I table it, or don’t send it at all.
- Stand up. If I want my comment to be anonymous, I ask myself what I’m ashamed of.
- Be Brief. If my comment is more than 3 sentences long, I save it for the topic of my next article.
Reg Adkins writes on behavior and the human experience at (elementaltruths.blogspot.com).
















Commenting Tips…
Lifehack.org rounds up some nice commenting tips. As Debbie Weil notes, leaving a comment is fast becoming a nice way to softly pitch a blogger about a launch. Reginald Adkins on Lifehack.org suggests adding value, considering email if it’s personal…
[...] Tips Filed under: Weblogs PRadd to del.icio.us Lifehack.org rounds up some nice commenting tips. As Debbie Weil notes, leaving a comment isfast becoming a nice way to softly pitch a blogger about a launch. [...]
Commenting Tips…
Thanks to Steve Rubel for pointing out Lifehack.org’s useful guide to Commenting Tips.
Back in 1999, Shel Horowitz pointed out The Marketing Power of Discussion Lists. But, as discussion groups slowly go the way of Usenet newsgroups, comments on …..
Interesting. Pass the gravy would you?
[...] Here at coComment, we quite like these commenting tips given by Reg Adkins over at Lifehack. I personally like the opening paragraph very much: Posting a comment on someone’s website is like walking into their dining room and pulling a chair up to the table. If it’s your dining room table it can be a bit of a shock when someone shows up. [...]
Interesting analogy. I just wish that all visitors follow this when they leave comments on blog.
I normally just delete comments with no content and just a silly smiley or something!
[...] Commenting Tips – lifehack.org “Posting a comment on someone’s website is like walking into their dining room and pulling a chair up to the table. If it’s your dining room table it can be a bit of a shock when someone shows up.” (tags: blogging writing tips comment comments) [...]
[...] Reg Adkins recently posted some excellent tips on commenting. From the standpoint of the small business blogger, or a writer looking to get some eyeballs on their stuff, his first tip – adding value – is key. [...]
[...] Commenting Tips – lifehack.org (tags: Blog) [...]
[...] Not long ago I did a piece on commenting etiquette. It was fairly well received, picked up quite a bit of traffic and was cited around in several locations. But, I may have communicated a message I did not intend. [...]
I think these blog is really useful for new comers and Excellent resource list.
I think these blog is really useful for new comers and Excellent resource list.
[...] Commenting Tips Posting a comment on someone’s website is like walking into their dining room and pulling a chair up to the table. If it’s your dining room table it can be a bit of a shock when someone shows up. [...]
[...] Commenting Tips [...]
have a nice meal……
“On the other hand, lacing your comments with profanity and insults is rather like sitting up to their table and breaking free with a horrendous blast of flatulence”
this is it!
[...] at coComment, we quite like these commenting tips given by Reg Adkins over at Lifehack. I personally like the opening paragraph very much: Posting a [...]
pagina muy interesante y con muchas informaciones, gracias
Wenn wir auf diesem Planeten weiter existieren wollen, müssen wir umdenken. “Jetzt ist nicht die Zeit für halbherzige Aktionen. Es fängt im Kleinen an. Machen Sie auch mit? Es lohnt sich für uns alle!
Alles wir Gut..
its very cool
There are many useful informations in this article. Thanks and greetings from Thuringia!
Hi, ok i think the Site is ok .
I think these blog is really useful for new comers and Excellent resource list.
good site
Gerettings Bayerischer Wald
I love the analogy. I can’t stand it on my blog when people just start swearing in the comments or saying rude things about other people. It’s totally inappropriate and it’s the kind of thing they’d never do in my living room (I hope).
I would leave a comment if I find something interesting. Otherwise, I would leave it alone. When moderating comments, apart from spams, I would delete rude comments.
Very usefull tips.Thanks.
its very very cool
pagina muy interesante y con muchas informaciones, gracias
Thanks for sharing bro, nice post ;)
interesting article on blog manners. what do you make of comment spammers?
Welcome to the Center for Natural Health Care and Healing in Berkeley, California. Emphasis on acupuncture, homeopathic medicine, and nutrition.
Really very important information for me. Because i am new in this work.
I agree with you. but mostly blog not post comment same time. They take more time & Some blog not option to website address for link.
Man I?m impressed with this informative blog, and in fact you hav a genius mind. keep up the good work.
BigCommerce Reviews
nteresting analogy. I just wish that all visitors follow this when they leave comments on blog.
Interesting ideas, I’ve never thought of them. again what ever you have written is appropriate. Yes, one should e-mail, rather spoiling relationship…
how do i post my interesting ideas? such as i have interesting on good start of Blog commenting. What type of keywords i have search? because i am new to blog commenting….
Very
useful information particularly the last part I care for such
information a lot.
One of the great topic you choose for post and there is no doubt that commenting tips are necesary for everyone because nowadays blogging increasing rapidly and i thin in this new year 2012 it will increas up to 200 percents. Therefore, these commenting tips are very helpful for our future.
very nice and good to read, i wish that every one will like this very much express gratitude for the posting
E mail service provider