4 Reasons Positive Thinking Doesn’t Work (And What to Do Instead)
April 19 by Marvin Abisia in Lifestyle, Uncategorized | 521 Shares
Don’t you just love how whenever you’re struggling with a goal or problem, the first thing anyone tells you is, “It’s okay, just think positive!”
While the advice is well-meaning, I’m sure most of the time you met it with a grateful, “Thanks for the encouragement. Yeah, I’ll do that.”
Secretly, you thought to yourself:
“That’s a bunch of B.S. I can’t just Vulcan mind-meld myself into conquering this problem!”
You know what? You’re absolutely right.
Willing yourself to results and applying the so-called “Law of Attraction” by simply focusing on the outcome you want was popularized a few years back by programs such as The Secret. But the fact is, positive thinking alone does nothing in the way of getting you results. This is true whether your goal has to do with attaining a certain level of wealth or completing a marathon.
Below are four reasons positive thinking alone fails to deliver results. To achieve your big goals you need to focus most of your energy on positive action instead.
You Need Feedback
For progress of any kind, you need a continuous feedback loop. Every improvement you experience stimulates and rewards your brain, making you feel good about the accomplishment. When you feel good about something you’ve done, you get more motivated to keep doing it.
When you experience a setback, sitting there thinking about how great the situation could become does little to make that possibility a reality.
It’s the positive action that gets you back on track as you reinforce in your mind that your action is producing results and getting you that much closer to your goal.
You Need Measurable Progress
The ability to track your progress is essential if you are to successfully achieve any goal. There is an explicit set of actions needed to get to your goal. When you complete any of those actions, it becomes a record of your progress towards that goal.
While thinking every day about how great it will be when you cross the finish line is helpful to keep you going, it is not the same as actually doing what it takes to get there.
Imagine if a coach were to ask you, “How did you do today? Can I review what you worked on?” And you replied, “I didn’t log any activity today…but I really spent a lot of time thinking positively about it!”
It’s silly to imagine this conversation taking place, but it really illustrates the importance of positive action over positive thinking.
You Need Accountability
The idea of being able to attract positivity and success into your life by simply thinking about it more often than others leaves out an important ingredient for reaching your goals:
Accountability. Without this key ingredient, all the positive thinking in the world won’t help you.
You could think about earning a gold medal…but they’re not just going to hand it to you. You’ve got to be the one to work for it.
You could focus on amassing a million dollars…but people don’t just hand out money to you for thinking positive. You’ve got to build something of value before you’ll get paid.
You Need To Be Realistic
Even the most successful people in the world experience negativity in their lives. Less than desirable events can and will happen to us no matter how much energy we spend trying to think positive. It’s naïve to believe that we can positively think away our problems.
Don’t get me wrong. Thinking positive goes a long way in changing your perspective on how to achieve goals in your life. But you’ve got to accept that there will be negative things that happen to you, and then act quickly to overcome them.
It’s like the saying goes,
“When life hands you lemons, make lemonade!”
It doesn’t say think about lemonade, or wish you never got the lemons. It says to make lemonade. That’s positive action for you!
Producing any positive outcome in your life demands a progressive series of actions. Without action, there is little chance that you will “attract” any success in your life, other than a short-lived moment of bliss.
Thinking positive doesn’t make debts go away. You’ve got to take action to address them. A positive self-image goes a long way in getting healthy. But you’ve still got to put in the energy to exercise and eat properly to become truly healthy.
So the next time you hear someone tell you, “It’s okay. Just think positive,” say to them:
“You know what? You’re right. Now if you’ll excuse me, I’ve got to go and make some lemonade!”
(Photo credit: Alex Proimos)











There’s a lot to this idea… the problem is that people tend to assume positive thinking *alone* will work. It doesn’t. What works is positive *action*. My take on it is that it’s easier to take positive action as the result of positive thinking than negative thinking but there are no promises.
Positive thinking might work, or it might not… negative thinking won’t though, so you might as well give it a go… and back it up with getting off your ass and DOING something! :)
So true Simon! For a long time I didn’t take action on so many things that weren’t working right in my life. When I finally did….things just blew up! (in a good way). Thanks for the comment!
Thanx Simon, we should all adopt your ideology on this…!
I get it…
Positive thinking without positive action equals negative life.
Hi Glori! Thanks for the comment. It won’t necessarily result in a negative life. It simply means that your present state cannot improve or progress unless you act upon those positive thoughts. For example, if I am thinking about having a leaner figure…that’s great. But I have to do something (exercise, eat properly) before that will happen. It’s great to be inspired by something you watch or read…but it’s what you DO with that inspiration that makes a difference in your life.
Hi Glori! Thanks for the comment. It won’t necessarily result in a negative life. It simply means that your present state cannot improve or progress unless you act upon those positive thoughts. For example, if I am thinking about having a leaner figure…that’s great. But I have to do something (exercise, eat properly) before that will happen. It’s great to be inspired by something you watch or read…but it’s what you DO with that inspiration that makes a difference in your life.
Great post Marvin, goals without action are just dreams!
Thanks for the comment Ciara, and thanks again for extending an opportunity to me. I’m grateful to have the chance to share my message with the world, and you’ve impacted not only me…but countless others in the club!
The gap between positive thinking and positive action is much greater than negative thinking and positive thinking.
Asking someone to think positive who is in a negative state is like encouraging them to begin at the trailhead. No, they won’t be at the summit, but the great journey begins with a single step.
I believe those who respond negatively to being challenged to think positive, simply weren’t able to rise to the challenge that is thinking positive and are actually those who need it most.
Well said Michael. You’re right, it’s very easy to get stuck in the positive/negative thinking game. It’s so much more effective to take action, and then correct course along the way as necessary. It’s essentially, “I don’t know if this will work or not, but I will try(action) and see where it takes me.”
I’ve also heard about recent studies saying things like aiming (too) high leads to disappointment (think along the lines of perfectionism); and similarly, that students who get A’s aren’t aiming as high as those who get Bs/Cs; the latter are usually aiming for A’s, however. :P
I also saw something a few days ago that contrasted “defensive pessimism” with “strategic optimism”, saying both have strengths and weaknesses. The weaknesses, they said, of being strategically optimistic, are that you might often feel let down if you experience a negative outcome. So this all makes sense to me. Also, thinking and doing are two different things, and thinking something doesn’t necessarily mean you’re actucally intrinsically motivated to DO it, especially when you’re thinking a certain way (in this case, optimistically) because someone else told you to. ;)
I disagree with this article. Positive thinking does work in all aspects of life. Most people do not understand how the concept works. You cannot just sit on the couch thinking positively about ten thousand dollars and it will drop into your lap. There is much more to the concept than that, positive thinking works in a way that it ‘attracts’ situations in life that give you what you want, done all through your thoughts and actions. Positive thinking is a form of focusing on what you want and everyone knows that when you focus hard enough you can achieve almost anything. These concepts of the laws of attraction and similar concepts were written hundreds of years ago.
You focus or concentrate on what you want, think positive, maintain a positive mindset and continue to think about it everyday and situations will fall into place to make this happen. I have witnessed this first hand, financial and health conditions completely transformed. As I was when I first learnt this concept I did not believe it would work until I saw it work for loved ones. Most people try this, think positive and then get impatient and therefore ruin what they have worked towards. Similar to a boy growing a tree, he plants the seed, waters it but if he does not continue to water it but dig it up out of frustration then this tree will never grow. Over and over we hear that you get what you put in, that is exactly right, you put in the work, the mental work and you will get results. If anyone wishes to read more I recommend The Master Key System, you can download a free PDF online of this book that was written over a hundred years ago. “The mind is everything, what you think is what you become” – Buddah
That is so to the point. Our actions show our true intent, and make things happen. Too
often positive thinking is used as a way keep things under control. I think we confuse being negative with
looking at things in a different way.
Having a different view is not being negative, but reflects our differences as human
beings. We need to be open minded and look at things in all lights, as this
allows us to make better decisions. I may not agree with something, but that
does not make me negative. It’s what I do with that information, after reviewing
it. that gives me and advantage, and allows me to see things; I may not if I
fear being labeled as negative. We all have a right, and should state our
opinions. They may not be accepted, but we all have importance. In the end what
counts are our actions – How we follow through – Words without action lead to
nothing, even if they are positive. We should not be afraid to disagree
I don’t quite agree with how you put it. It is true that by JUST THINKING without the ACTION, things won’t just happen. However, the principle is just like lightning or thunder comes first. Without thinking positively, often times, there won’t be any action at all just like the car without the fuel. It is all about the right mentality creating the right action.
- Financejobguru
Thanx stacey, i agree with you, Coz the way he put his like “4 reasons positive thing doesnt work” i mean true it wont work without positive actions just like you say, How can you run atruck without petrol?
But seriously, if any one thought that u can conquer your problems with just thinking positively, I will call that real Bs, Positive thinking don’t achieve any thing if you cant really put your thinking to positivity, Otherwise it would have been acarrier by now, you know where one just positive thinks and things materialise.
Think it, love it, plan, put your all to it, and never Give up, with that theres only one result “SUCCESS”
I've never been under the illusion that a postive thought alone was going to make anything better. Not one deliberate action has ever been taken without first having the thought to take it. I think this whole issue is being beaten to death. When you read anything about positive thinking….and it's positive affects…I think most people know that the thinking alone isn't going to do anything for them..it's kind of a given. There are people who have and are trying to change their lives by having a more positive attitude. It really bothers me to see articles like this….it's kind of like spitting in the face of people who do believe in this. What doesn't work for you or others is not the end all be all for what will or will not work for someone else. Like I said, I don't think anyone reads a positive thinking book and thinks that just by mere thought alone..they are going to bring into their life whatever their heart desires. That's just kinda dumb. It's just plain commonsense that the positive thoughts are meant to go with positive actions. The tone to this article is undesirable and I'm not sure why anyone would want to put a dark cloud over something such as positive thinking. To me, that's just negativity at it's most extreme.It may not work for you…you may see it as dumb…but it has worked for many others…and these many others had the commonsense to know that the books they were reading weren't suggesting that positive thinking alone would do anybody any good. EVERYBODY knows that action is required.