I cannot count the number of times I’ve either heard my coaching clients or parents on the street say, “My child just doesn’t listen to me!” or “Why can’t he/she just listen?”
There are two issues here:
1. The child doesn’t have a healthy level of respect for the parents’ authority (as hard as this may be to admit)
2. The parent is making the request at the wrong time.
Luckily, there are two great solutions to these issues.
I’ll never forget my first year of teaching. I was fresh out of university and was hired to teach French to a class that had gotten two other teachers to quit; they saw me as their new challenge and boy did they challenge me! I spent months trying to use every technique I had ever been taught – nothing worked. I tried talking to them, bribing them, yelling at them, punishing them, rewarding them yet nothing seemed to improve. One day I called the parent of one of the more difficult students to inform them, once again, of their son’s rude behaviour. The response I got from the father shook me to my core. He said, “Look, I can’t make him respect you. You have to do that.” How embarrassing!
“What do I do now?” I thought. After a lot of thought, prayer and contemplation I devised a 4 step discipline technique that I would try to use over and over again; I was tired of trying so many different strategies. And truly, once I really thought about things, I realized that the kids didn’t know what to expect from me because I kept changing my relationship and expectations with them.
It only took a few days to notice a HUGE improvement and by the end of that year even the most difficult kids cried at having to leave my class and move on to a new teacher. I had earned their respect and when I asked them to do something…or not to do something, they intrinsically wanted to listen.
This is what every parent needs to do. Once respect is there, not just love, but a genuine respect, then parenting becomes easy, simple and an extremely joyful, stress-free experience.
Using a simple, consistent form of discipline is key, as is enjoying special moments together as a family and spending one-on-one time with each child. Furthermore, specific praise as well as non-verbal praise needs to be present. If all of these areas are present between parent and child you’ve got yourself a winning situation and a child who will listen to you.
The second issue I see as being a problem with parents I coach is in the timing of their request.
We have our own agendas and when we want out kids to do something we want it done NOW so we can move on to our next task. Although this is understandable, we must understand and respect that our children have their own agendas and even though they seem trivial to us, they are very important to our kids. No one likes spur-of-the-moment interruptions, so be considerate.
When you want you child to do something try to:
a) Give a countdown. “Sally, in 5 minutes it’s time to eat dinner.” Or, “In 5 minutes it’s time to clean up.” Then gently count down.
b) Make the request after their TV program is over, during a commercial or at least not during an exciting part. If you have the option to pause the movie or program do so, then make your request, but be very specific. For example, “After this show it’s time to ________.”
c) Use praise or thank you’s when your child listens well. For example, “Thanks for coming so quickly after your program was finished, I appreciate that.” Then solidify the compliment with a quick smile, back rub, thumbs up, or squeeze of the hand.
Putting a few things into practice will change the dynamics in your family dramatically, as well as your relationship with your child – what’s better than that?








Your advice is good; I should know, I’ve used that with my own kids. But that parent was way out of line. It IS his job to deliver a kid who will behave at school. Yeah, he can’t make the kid respect you. No one can force anyone to respect anyone else. However, he CAN and SHOULD insist that the kid credibly fake that respect, if nothing else.
I have to disagree, it’s a parents job to teach their children the best practices when dealing with other people. And then teach them that their are consequences of not following social norms. (dislike, anger, threats, retribution) However the children (small people) have every right as a human being to choose how they will interact. A lack of actual respect for a person is good reason to only treat them with common courtesy unless they have become apparent to you they don’t even deserve that.
Some good info here.
A few comments: 1) I’m not sure why, in an article offering advice, you would mention you “devised a 4 step discipline technique that you would try to use over
and over again. . .that only took a few days to notice a HUGE improvement” – yet not describe the plan was you came up with. Details are the key to useful articles like these. If you plan to reveal that in a later article you may want to mention it, otherwise, the hinting around comes across as holding out, or that it didn’t really exist (I’m not saying etiher is the case, just that it appears that way).
2) I may not be perfectly consistent, but I’ve tried the countdown/better timing/praise good behavior techniques over and over and unfortunately my 6 yr old sees thru them as intentional strategies and they just haven’t worked. The only thing she responds to is the threat of having something taken away, which is no fun for anyone. ):
I’ve taught both martial arts and skiing to kids over the years. One thing I always notice is that any of the kids that have potential discipline and behaviour issues, have parents that seem to be too soft on them. I’m never surprised when I meet these parents. Your points and suggestions are great. They will make a difference. I would also advocate that kids try out martial arts programs where they have no choice but to behave well during classes. Kids who stay in good martial arts programs usually are quite disciplined and respectful towards others.
Good post, but it can be summed up in a few words. ”Treat your children like people, and they will give you the same courtesy back.” To clarify that, ask yourself would I like to be addressed or treated in this manner?” If the answer is no, the small person is not going to like it any better than you.
Good post, but it can be summed up in a few words. ”Treat your children like people, and they will give you the same courtesy back.” To clarify that, ask yourself would I like to be addressed or treated in this manner?” If the answer is no, the small person is not going to like it any better than you.
This sounded like a good post but nothing happened. What did you do to earn their respect? I’ve read it again, nothing there.
Thought-provoking. I would add a couple things. I am not surprised children don’t respond when parents use soft voices and are not fully present. They don’t sound like they mean it. You mean it when you speak from your diaphragm and are present. But more importantly, respect is a two way street – respect your children, respect their dignity as humans.
I’m sneaking in a third thing – do you respect yourself? Often we expect others, including our children, to do for us what we can’t do for ourselves.
To be honest I absolutely despise it when a parent or person of authority thanks me for doing something they asked. I feel as though they think I wouldn’t have done that task, like cleaning, unless they had asked me and that is what makes me want to lash out violently.
Is it weird that my most violent thoughts are triggered by authoritarian people giving me praise for a task that I would have gotten around to on my own.
I am less likely to want to do something if a parent wants me to do it.
For example for years I didn’t exercise because my mom wanted me to. She was constantly telling me the benefits of exercising. I didn’t want my mom to think that her nagging was the reason I was exercising so I didn’t exercise.
Then I while later my mom gave up and stopped nagging me, I let some time pass and even before my mom’s advice I had already known the benefits of exercise from the internet. I developed my own exercise and nutrition guideline and found exercising to be easier and more enjoyable because it was something that I did ALONE.
The only thing I can relate these feeling to is when you buy something you WANT for yourself, you cherish more than if someone else bought it for you.
To be honest I absolutely despise it when a parent or person of authority thanks me for doing something they asked. I feel as though they think I wouldn’t have done that task, like cleaning, unless they had asked me and that is what makes me want to lash out violently.
Is it weird that my most violent thoughts are triggered by authoritarian people giving me praise for a task that I would have gotten around to on my own.
I am less likely to want to do something if a parent wants me to do it.
For example for years I didn’t exercise because my mom wanted me to. She was constantly telling me the benefits of exercising. I didn’t want my mom to think that her nagging was the reason I was exercising so I didn’t exercise.
Then I while later my mom gave up and stopped nagging me, I let some time pass and even before my mom’s advice I had already known the benefits of exercise from the internet. I developed my own exercise and nutrition guideline and found exercising to be easier and more enjoyable because it was something that I did ALONE.
The only thing I can relate these feeling to is when you buy something you WANT for yourself, you cherish more than if someone else bought it for you.
* You can make and enforce the request. Do not expect to see a happy smiling response if it isn’t what they want to do. If they are doing what you asked – even grudgingly, thank them and back down mentally and physically. Do not allow your body language to show that you continue to be displeased.